When you’re in your 40s and seeking an online dating site, you’re going to be in one of two situations:
- You’re single and have never been married.
- You’ve been married before and attempting to get back in the saddle again.
Either way, when you’re in your 40s and looking for an online dating site, the criteria used to evaluate those sites can differ from the criteria used by 20- and 30-somethings. Many of them are into mobile-only apps like Tinder or Hinge, which are location based and connected to their Facebook accounts. While novel in the world of online dating, those mobile-only apps cater primarily to that younger crowd so they’re not super helpful for people in their 40s. That doesn’t mean you can’t find someone while using them, it just means it’s going to be more difficult than if you were in your twenties.
Forty-something Christians are probably less interested in the cool factor of an app or how many dates they can go on anyway. They’re more concerned about simply finding people who love Jesus and will commit. For them, price matters, but then again it doesn’t as long as it results in marriage.
Then there are those of us forty-somethings who want the entire package—a modern, well-designed site, a lot of match options, relatively inexpensive memberships, and matches who love Jesus and will commit. We’re not asking for too much, we don’t think…
It doesn’t matter what your motivation is for finding the Best Christian Dating Sites for Over 40 because we’ve got you covered. We’ll break it down for you by various categories so you can make an educated decision for yourself about which one might be the best option for you.
Ready? Let’s take a look at how the 5 sites we’ve declared as the top 5 in Christian dating measure up—eharmony, Match.com, Christian Mingle, Christian Café, and Christian Crush.
Who Has the Most Forty Something Users?
For some, the number of members a site has is the single biggest factor when considering an online dating site. The way they see it, online dating is a numbers game, and the more the merrier…er, the more options they have, even if the database consists of more than Christians.
eharmony has been around since 2000 and makes over 15 million matches a day. They consider their core demographic to be 35-65 year olds who are interested in marriage.
Match was the first of the online dating sites, having been launched in 1995 and has around 10 million users. Nearly half of Match users are in the 30-49 year old age bracket, and the 50+ crowd is their fastest growing segment.
Christian Mingle came on the scene in 2001. It bills itself as “the largest and fastest growing online community of Christian singles.” As of 2016, it had over 9 million registered users.
So considering those numbers, if having access to the most matches possible is your priority in your site for Christian Online Dating Sites for Over 40, then Christian Café and Christian Crush probably won’t be the best sites for you. Conducting nationwide searches for both sexes on both sites will net you a couple of hundred matches each. While you’ll probably mainly have like-minded Christian matches on those two sites—because they are specifically targeting Christians—their user base is fairly small when compared to the Big Three, eharmony, Match, and Christian Mingle.
SingleRoots Recommendation: eharmony, Match.com, and Christian Mingle
Which Site Is the Easiest to Use?
So you weren’t a part of the latest generation that grew up with cell phones in their hands since birth? Ok, but you are a part of the generation that saw Al Gore invent the internet, and you probably had dial-up access and an email account in your early- to mid-twenties. So, you’re not exactly new to technology. However, you are a busy person and you don’t have time for online dating sites that have a large learning curve. We hear you, and we’re here to help.
While it may take 15-20 minutes to take the personality inventory for eharmony, hands down it’s the easiest site out there. That’s probably because you don’t get access to the entire database of eharmony users. They send you an average of 7 matches per day for you to peruse and you decide if you want to converse with them. Because you’re not conducting daily searches, eharmony is a pretty straightforward, easy-to-use site for both the technologically-challenged user or the tech-savvy one. The profiles are easy to read and their matching process is easy to understand.
Match.com, Christian Mingle, and Christian Café have a slightly larger learning curve because they come with more search options, chat features, as well as other bells and whistles. That’s not to say that those three sites are difficult to figure out, but it does take a little more time and effort to understand all of their features when compared to eharmony.
Christian Crush is fairly straightforward, too, but it’s not as user friendly. The site involves more than online dating (Christian Counseling, marriage seminars, and porn seminars are also offered), so it can be a little cumbersome to find the online dating portion of the site. Once you’re in the site, conducting a search is simple enough, but the user experience could be better. Things like enlarging photos and returning to the home page need work. They also offer the option of uploading a video to your profile, which is a nice option that the others don’t have, but it might prove to be slightly difficult for some users.
SingleRoots Recommendation: eharmony
Which Sites Are the Best for Finding Christians?
So one would probably guess that the sites with the word “Christian” in the title are the greatest options for finding the best Christian online datings sites for over 40. And that’s true…for the most part. Keep reading, though.
Using a site that specifically targets the Christian demographic, like Christian Mingle, Christian Café, or Christian Crush, is a good way to wade through the non-Christian matches on an online dating site. Granted, not all of those “Christian” sites are going to deliver Christians, let alone Christians that have the same level of commitment to Christ that you have, but they are a good start.
The problem goes back to the numbers conversation we had earlier. Christian Café and Christian Crush just don’t have the membership numbers that the Big Three—eharmony, Match.com, and Christian Mingle—have. Christian Mingle has the largest user base of the sites that specifically target Christians. Again, that doesn’t mean every user is going to be a Christian—not everyone tells the truth on the internet and not everyone defines the term “Christian” in the same way—but Christians are the demographic the site is targeting, nonetheless.
Christian Café has been around since 1999, and although we don’t know exact membership numbers, we do know that our research shows searches significantly less members in several age groups. However, the site does boast that they’ve seen over 25,000 marriages from their site.
If you’re in the Colorado area, Christian Crush might be a good option for you because it is located in Colorado and their user base relies heavily upon local singles. That’s not to say that it won’t work for those living beyond Colorado, but the chances are far less if you live elsewhere.
While eharmony isn’t a Christian-specific site, there’s something to be said for their personality inventory and your personal management of your match settings. Over and over, we hear from Christians who have met their spouses on eharmony more than we do from any other online dating site. Sure, you will be given the occasional non-Christian, but if you control your settings correctly, you’ll find their algorithm is pretty good about sending you Christian matches.
SingleRoots Recommendation: eharmony, Christian Mingle, and Christian Café
Which Site Gives the Most Control?
One of the arguments we hear against eharmony is that users aren’t allowed access to the entire database of eharmony. And that’s true. The algorithm matches you with users that fit your settings, as well as your personality. There’s also a “What If?” feature that you can scroll through to determine your interest in matches who don’t quite meet all of your setting criteria, but that’s the extent of your ability to control eharmony.
The other 4 sites—Match, Christian Mingle, Christian Café, and Christian Crush—allow you to search their sites fully to see all of their matches at any age. If the ability to view, search, and communicate with anyone and everyone is of utmost importance to you as you search online for dates, then you’ll be pleased with any of those four.
SingleRoots Recommendation: Match.com, Christian Mingle, Christian Café, and Christian Crush
Which Sites Have Mobile Options?
We live in a mobile world. Most of you are probably even reading this post from your phone or tablet, so it stands to reason that you want your online dating on-the-go, too. The good news is that all of the of the sites except Christian Crush offer fully-functioning mobile apps that allow you to view matches and communicate with them from your phone or tablet.
SingleRoots Recommendation: eharmony, Match.com, Christian Mingle, and Christian Cafe
Which Site Is the Cheapest?
It goes without saying that these are paid online dating sites and they’re going to cost you something. But you’re not a struggling twenty something anymore and you’re willing to pay to find serious Christian matches, right? Some of the sites are more expensive than others; however, if you check our coupon block at the bottom of the page, we update it whenever we’re notified of new discounts that might help offset your quest to find love, true love.
Another thing to remember is the more months you sign up for, the greater your discount will probably be. Experts will tell you it takes a good 3 months, on average, to find something meaningful online. A one-month membership is a little short-sighted because it takes a little while to figure out the site, start communicating, and learn what you are and are not looking for, so keep that in mind when you’re determining the best site for you. But, if online dating makes you nervous, a one-month membership is a good way to get your feet wet and try it out.
It’s a fact that eharmony is the most expensive site on the list. One month on eharmony, without a discount, can run you nearly $60. But if you sign up for a year, you can see those monthly rates drop to around $20 a month.
Match.com, Christian Mingle, and Christian Café are usually similarly priced and run under $35 for a one-month subscription and can go as low as $15 for longer subscriptions, if not lower.
Christian Crush comes in the lowest priced, charging $14.99 for one month, or going as low as $8.33 a month for a 6-month subscription. If you upload a video on your Christian Crush profile, you can receive 2 weeks free.
SingleRoots Recommendation: Christian Crush
Best Christian Dating Site for Over 40 :: SingleRoots Recommends
If you’re looking for the best Christian dating sites for over 40, it’s our recommendation that you try eharmony first.
Our research shows that more Christian singles are using eharmony and finding marriage on that site than any of the others. Match.com and Christian Mingle are good alternatives, but the eharmony personality assessment, along with strict setting options about religious preferences, help to insure more like-minded matches are delivered to your inbox instead of you having to wade through thousands of profiles to search for them. Granted, you won’t have as much control over your selections and it will be a little more expensive than those other sites, but there are going to be downsides no matter which site you choose. Ultimately, the Over 40 Crowd is the heart of the eharmony demographic, so you’re going to have more matches than the twenty somethings anyway.
While certainly imperfect, we think you’ll find your time and money are best used on eharmony, so we recommend it as the best Christian online dating site for over 40.
And to help you get started, here are the most up-to-date deals we are aware of for each online dating site:
Current Online Dating Deals:
Last Updated: 5/23/2023
eharmony (USA Offers):
- Special Promo Link & Code: Get 25% Off Any Length Membership at eharmony! Use this link & code at checkout: SINGLEROOTS25
eharmony (Canada Offers):
- EXCLUSIVE Promo: Get a
10-day17-Day ChristianCafe.com FREE trial! Use this LINK to get offer :: Use Promo Code: SingleRoots17
Best Christian Dating Sites Rankings
|Monthly Price Range||Number of Members||Ease of Use||Christian Filters||Best Deal Link|
|$19.95 to $59.95|
Tip: How to Get an eharmony Free Trial
|High||Simple||Excellent||25% Off Any Membership! Use this link with this code at checkout: SINGLEROOTS25|
|$12.49 to $29.99||High||Simple||Fair||Browse Zoosk for Free!|
|$16.99 to $32.99||High||Option-Overload||Good||Review your Christian Mingle matches for free!|
|$8.99 to $34.97||Medium||Option-Overload||Excellent||EXCLUSIVE 17-Day Free Trial! Use this link with this code at checkout: SINGLEROOTS17|